Welcome
The Painted Cookie - Custom Sugar Cookies & Decorated Treats in NJ
Handcrafted cookies that taste as good as they look.
Custom sugar cookies & specialty treats for all of life's sweet moments!
Menu / Price List
Custom Sugar Cookies
Vanilla-Almond sugar cookies decorated with vanilla royal icing. These cookies are fully customizable allowing you to choose the shape and design that best fit your needs. They are perfect for any occasion and make great party favors, dessert platters, or a sweet gift! Add-ons available
Standard
Start at $55/dozen
1 dozen minimum
Each cookie is about 3.5-4.5 +/- inches
White & up to 4 colors, up to 4 shapes/designs
Additional colors/designs + $5
Each cookie will be individually heat sealed
Minis
Start at $45/dozen
2 dozen minimum (1 dozen if ordered with Standard sized cookies)
Each cookie is about 2 +/- inches
Minis are a great way to balance out a platter or offer a smaller bite for your guests
Each cookie will be individually heat sealed
Add-Ons
Metallics (Gold, Silver, Rose Gold, etc.) + $5/dozen
Florals + $5/dozen
Individually heat sealed & tied with matching ribbon + $7/dozen
Drop Cookies
Giant, soft, and chewy! Available in 3 sizes. Choose from classic and gourmet flavors, with new options always being added. Available in mini 4-packs, regular (3 oz), and jumbo (6 oz). Gourmet flavors +$0.50.
Chocolate Chip
A classic loaded with milk chocolate chips. Available in mini, regular, and jumbo.
Mini Cookies - Sold in 4-packs, $8
Regular Cookies - $3 each
Jumbo Cookies - $6 each
Cookies & Cream
Loaded with pieces of Hershey's Cookies 'n' Creme bars and chopped Oreo's!
Available in mini, regular, and jumbo.
Mini Cookies - Sold in 4-packs, $10
Regular Cookies - $3.50 each
Jumbo Cookies - $6.50 each
Brown Butter Chocolate Chunk
Giant, crispy edges and soft & chewy center! Semi-sweet chocolate chunks in every bite. Topped with flaky sea salt.
Available in mini, regular and jumbo.
Mini Cookies - Sold in 4-packs, $10
Regular Cookies - $3.50 each
Jumbo Cookies - $6.50 each
Sugar Cookies
Fun activities for both kids and adults!
Paint Your Own Cookies
$7
These cookies each come with a mini paintbrush, edible paint palette that acts like watercolor, and instructions.
Each cookie will be individually heat-sealed with the painting items!
$7 each or 2 for $13
DIY Cookie Kits
$30
Each kit includes 6 sugar cookies, 4 bags of royal icing, sprinkles, and an instructions sheet.
Boxes can be fully customized (theme, shapes, colors, etc)
Name Cookie Kits
From $8
2 Options Available: DIY or PYO.
Each kit comes with cookies spelling out their name or word(s) of your choice.
These are a fun activity for both kids and adults!
-DIY kits come with naked letters, icing and sprinkles!
-PYO kits come with the letters already iced white, a paint pallet, and paint brush
$8 base price plus $3 per letter.
Additional shapes can be added
Examples
*ELLIE- $8 base + $15 letters = $23 total
*ELLIE- $8 base + $15 letters + $9 hearts = $32 total
Eat, you'll feel better!
About The Painted Cookie
Hi, I’m Jackie! The baker, decorator, and dough-obsessed creator behind The Painted Cookie
I started decorating cookies in 2021 as a fun hobby, and it quickly became so much more. What began as experimenting in my kitchen turned into a creative passion and eventually, my home bakery. I absolutely love bringing designs to life and baking treats that make people smile.
The Painted Cookie is proudly run from my home with the love and support of my wonderful husband and our two amazing kids. They’re my biggest cheerleaders and often help with taste testing, packaging, and even the dreaded dishes!
I can’t wait to bake something special for you. Place an order and let me add a little sweetness to your day!
Our Mission
At The Painted Cookie, our mission is to make your celebrations sweeter with handcrafted treats made with care, creativity, and high-quality ingredients. We believe cookies should not only look beautiful but taste incredible too.
From birthdays and weddings to corporate events and holidays, we’re committed to providing exceptional service and memorable treats for every occasion.
We proudly offer custom sugar cookies, drop cookies, cookie cakes, cake pops, and chocolate-covered Oreos, pretzels, and Rice Krispie treats - all baked fresh in our NJ home kitchen.